Spike (Buffyverse)

From Fanlore
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Name: Spike, William the Bloody
Occupation: vampire, failed poet
Relationships: Drusilla, Buffy, Angel, Fanged Four
Fandom: Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel the Series
Other: Spike on Wikipedia
Click here for related articles on Fanlore.
art by Frank V. Liltz (1999)

Spike is a vampire from the Joss Whedon TV shows Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel the Series. He was played by James Marsters.

Spike was an enormously popular character. Orginally introduced as Season two's Little Bad, Spike became a series regular in season four after many guest appearances. Although people had been writing about him ever since his introduction in season two, Spike-centric fanac exploded during season five, with his shift from comically obnoxious antihero to lovesick woobie (evil woobie, thanks very much. but still: woobie). This change in his function on the show, and every subsequent change for the next four years, provoked vast amounts of angst, joy, wank and fanac. Fans were compelled by Spike's slow, fraught shifts of allegiance, and argued vigorously about whether a soulless vampire could ever really propel himself into redemption.

In season five, Buffy/Spike emerged as a potentially serious canonical rival to Buffy/Angel. This resulted in the Bangel vs Spuffy ship war.


Redemtionistas vs. Evil!Spike

Within the Spike fanbase, there were two distinct groups of fans. Some fans, known as Redemptionistas, liked Spike's story of redemption and the others, the Evilistas, preferred to explore his evil side. These terms were in fairly widespread use before there was any hint of Spike's redemption arc in canon, and early theories focused on his ability to be redeemed when he lacked a soul. There was very little discussion of the possibility of Spike regaining his soul, as this appeared highly unlikely. According to the fandom glossary on Tabula Rasa:

Evilista: To an Evilista, Spike is forever owned by his basic vampire nature. He is unable to change, learn or grow, because he lacks a soul. He is eternally evil, unredeemable, forever and ever, amen.[1]

Redemptionistas: People who believe that Spike can be redeemed, despite his lack of a human soul. Redemptionistas come in many shapes, sizes and flavours. At BTVS-TabulaRasa, most of us believe that Spike will be redeemed through his interactions with the other characters, and especially Buffy. Originally, this term referred to MBTV posters who refused to see Spike as Just Another Evil Vampire. Redemptionistas look at Spike as an anomaly among vampirekind, they see his tremendous capacity for empathy and humanity. They (We!) believe that Spike can overcome his vampire nature to embrace his humanity.

In early seasons some show writers showed a noticeable preference for Evil Spike on public discussion forums, on which they interacted with fans. Writer David Fury was dismissive of any storyline which could result in a less evil Spike beginning a romance with Buffy, and some fans viewed his comments as insulting towards Spuffy shippers and redemptionistas.[2]

In fact it seems that a sizeable number of Redemptionistas were also early Spuffy shippers, who wanted to see a romantic relationship between Buffy and Spike, which would be impossible without a redemption arc. Spuffy was initially a rarepair and a crackship with other pairings more popular for both characters, and a large portion of the fandom did not understand the appeal. By season 5, Spuffy redemptionist fans felt unwelcome on fandom forums and lists and began to create their own fannish infrastructure.

On the fan side of things, the Evilistas (as they were called in those days) felt that the writers were on their side, and felt justified in attacking the Redemptionistas in similar terms. This is why the Bloody Awful Poet Society mailing list, which was founded at about this same time, grew to be the fannish monster that it did: for awhile, it was one of the few online spaces where you could talk about Spike or Spuffy without being attacked. (As Spuffy got more popular, several other Spuffy boards were created. All long dead now.)[3]

Icon from anti-redemptionista site Big Bad Forever.

Storylines in Seasons six and seven escalated the flame war between the evilistas and the redemtionistas. Spuffy became canon in season 6, but their relationship remained antagonistic. In episode 19, Seeing Red, Spike attempted to rape Buffy, in a scene which is referred to as the AR (attempted rape) or the Bathroom Scene. This was a hugely contentious scene which also escalated tensions in the Spuffy vs. Bangel ship war.

In the Season 6 finale, Spike succeeds in the Trials and his wish is granted; his soul was returned to him. There was debate in fandom about whether or not Spike intended to restore his soul when he wished to be made what he was. Remptionistas were more likely to believe Spike choose his soul, while fans who view Spike as principally an evil vampire were more likely to wonder if Spike's wish was misinterpreted. Some fans believe Spike intended to wish away his behaviour modification chip which prevented him from hurting humans. Redemtionistas and Evilistas remained entrenched in their opinions.

From what I gather, the "redemptionista" POV is that Spike is now a good guy, he's been redeemed and it just hasn't been acknowledged yet. And the "evilista" POV is that Spike is, was, and always will be pure total evil and nothing can ever change that. This difference of opinion between the two groups has gotten kinda nasty. The present point of contention between the two groups centers, of course, on The Bathroom Scene and what did/didn't/almost happened there. The "evilistas" seem to feel that the "redemptionistas" are excusing and justifying Spike's behavior by blaming Buffy for provoking him, while the "redemptionistas" seem to feel that the "evilistas" are being too simplistic in their interpretation of the scene. And neither side is listening to the other. And more moderate viewpoints are getting ground into pulp between them.[4]

Years after the TV series ended, the Buffy comics reignited debate about Spike's redemption and the role of his soul in that redemption.[5][6] In the mini-series, Spike, by Brian Lynch, Spike's soul was removed, but the character remained good, and did not revert to his evil ways. This was something Redemptionist fans had wanted back in Season 5 and 6; evidence of a soulless redemption.

But regardless, all the usual arguments have broken out, and the forums are aflame with Spike-haters saying that the capacity to do good without a soul proves Spike is THE WORSTEST MOST EVIL VAMPIRE EVER, and Spike fans saying that now his journey has been COMPLETELY INVALIDATED AND THE CHARCTER IS RUINED, and other Spike fans saying that despite Joss's supervision and approval of Lynch's script NO WAI ITS NOT CANON and yet other fans wailing OH NOES IF VAMPIRES CAN BE GOOD BUFFY IS A MURDERER! The arguments are largely straw men and false dualisms [7]

St. Spike vs. Buffy the Bitch

Season six was when Spike's relationship with Buffy became canon but the way their relationship developed (to some fans) left much to be desired. The character shift during that time was a source of much debate (in the fandom, as well as among Buffy/Spike shippers).

A certain tendency in fanfic could be noticed during that period where Spike was depicted as self-sacrificing (even before the soul), doing the right thing kind of guy, whereas Buffy was portrayed as more unstable, abusive partner. The tendency to portray Buffy as abusive was most common in fics pairing Spike with another, more understanding character. This was usually either Xander, who fans also believed was overlooked or abused in canon, or Angel, who understood Spike was not to blame for his terrible deeds because he was a vampire without a soul. However even in works pairing Buffy and Spike, the Scoobies could be portrayed as abusive towards Spike, with Buffy learning the error of her ways as the two embark on a romantic relationship. The portrayal of Spike in fics was a source of much discussion.

In fanfic, mostly written by Spike fans, we read many plots with a strange woman appearing during S5 or S6, telling the Scoobies how horrible they are to treat Spike that way, and that they should apologize to him. Usually these stories tend to erase Spike's mistakes and put full focus on the Scoobies' not so pleasant moments. The story ends with this woman fixing all the characters' issues and everybody live happily ever after with Spike ending up with either Buffy or Xander. Depends on the story: Spuffy or Spander.[8]

Spike, on the other does tend to become Saint!Spike. I think the difference between woobiefication/Marty Stuing and canonization is this: Spike's "flaws" don't go away nor are they ignored. Instead, those flaws are turned into "positives" for the character and are excused or handwaved.
They are fluffed off as being unimportant because: 1) he's a vampire and everyone knows that vampires are better than humans; 2) he's not really bad he's just built that way; 3) all the other Scoobies are, of course, worse than Spike because Spike "can't help it" without the soul while they "can help it" with their souls (leaving aside that this group tends to never give the Scoobies any slack for human failings...ever); 4) of course all demons and vampires are coded as "minorities" and therefore (meta-lly speaking) the Scoobies must be racists for killing demons and vampires, which, if left unchecked, would eat them and their neighbors.[9]

In the years after the show ended, there has been a tendency to portray Spike as the abuser rather than the abused.

While I loathe the fanficy St. Spike, where all of his S6 choices were Buffy’s fault, I also feel equally frustrated with the Tumblr St. Buffy, where all of her S6 choices were Spike’s fault. Because she did some seriously messed up shit to him and to deny that or blame it on him or suggest that he had it coming makes me every bit as uncomfortable and squicked as the inverse.[10]

"But for the Thorns," an undated illo by Suzan Lovett

Spike in Fanfic

Spike is the little black dress of Buffyverse fandom. He's been paired with everybody from Joyce Summers to Mr. Gordo[11], and a zillion crossover characters besides. Based on works on Ao3, his most popular ship is Buffy/Spike[12], two other most popular pairings - Spike/Xander[13] and Angel/Spike[14] - are following far behind. However much of the works produced in this fandom were originally housed on personal sites, Livejournal and a multitude of unconnected archives. As a result, Ao3 stats may not give an accurate representation of the popularity of these ships. There are substantial bodies of work pairing him with Tara, Illyria, Drusilla, Wesley, Willow and Giles. [15] See pairing pages for overviews of pairing-specific trends, influential authors, etc.

Spike-centric gen often explores his history before he came to Sunnydale, his brotherly relationship with Dawn, or his struggles with his self-identity and moral code.

After Spike earned his soul at the end of season six fandom, responded with A LOT of fanfic. Even before season seven premiered, fans wrote fics (in major part basing Spike's possible reactions on Angel) about how Spike deals with the soul. When the beginning of season seven showed Spike insanity as a result of getting back his soul, fanfic writers responded with a lot of Hurt/Comfort fics.

Example Fanworks

Notable Gen Stories

Notable Fanart

Notable Vids


Resources and Communities


  1. ^ Tabula Rasa fandom glossary
  2. ^ I’m dying to know why the heck David Fury would insult his own fanbase an ask on rahirah's Tumblr, 2018, accessed 9 June 2019.
  3. ^ I’m dying to know why the heck David Fury would insult his own fanbase an ask on rahirah's Tumblr, 2018, accessed 9 June 2019.
  4. ^ ...the Redemptionista Rag... a LJ post by Djinanna, May 8 2002. Quote taken from comment by djinanna, May 9 2002
  5. ^ Jossverse morality: updated? (musings on recent IDW comics) livejournal post by moscow_watcher, Mar 2011.
  6. ^ What Spike's Soul Means to Me livejournal post by gryfndor_godess, March 2011
  7. ^ Heh a livejournal post by rahirah, Mar 2011.
  8. ^ LusciousXander livejournal post 22 September 2006, accessed 3 June 2019.
  9. ^ Reply by liz_marcs to lusciousXander lj post September 22nd, 2006, accessed 3 June 2019.
  10. ^ rahirah said: Tumblr post by demandingbillydolls
  11. ^ Pairing list at allaboutspike.com, accessed 14 March 2009.
  12. ^ 3200 works in Buffy/Spike list at Archive of Our Own, archived link from 13 October 2016.
  13. ^ 1650 works in Spike/Xander list at Archive of Our Own, archived link from 11 October 2016
  14. ^ 906 works in Angel/Spike list at Archive of Our Own, archived link from 06 October 2016
  15. ^ Spike/Tara has 14 fics on AllAboutSpike and 45 works on Ao3. The gen pairing of Spike & Illyria has 2 works on AllAboutSpike and their romantic pairing has 48 works on Ao3. Spike/Drusilla has 48 works on All About Spike and 564 works on Ao3. Spike/Wesley have 19 works on AllAboutSpike and 155 works on Ao3. Spike/Giles has 8 works on All About Spike and 148 works on Ao3. Spike/Willow has 13 works on All About Spike and 361 works on Ao3. All stats as of 5 June 2019