Queer Fandom
Related terms: | Representation, Politics |
See also: | Slash, Femslash, Aro Fandom, Asexuality and Fandom, Sapphic Fandom, Mspec Fandom, Trans Characters in Fandom, Gender and Fandom, Homophobia in Fandom, Transphobia in Fandom, Queercoding, Queerbaiting |
Click here for related articles on Fanlore. | |
Fandom and the exploration of queerness have long gone hand in hand, whether in the form of slash, femslash or the multitude of other fanworks, discussions, metas and communities created by or about queer folk that have existed within the world of fandom.
Canon Representation
Early Examples
Implicit vs. Explicit
Though many source texts will make it clear the specific identity a queer character uses, in other cases, the texts themselves won't specify the exact sexuality of a character. This is particularly common in fandoms whose source texts have family friendly target audiences.
For example, two characters – Mulan and Ruby – from Once Upon A Time is never specified on screen. With Mulan the headcanons differ between whether she's bi or a lesbian, and with Ruby Lucas's, though given her onscreen relationships with both men and women, most people assume she's bi. However even with that context, headcanons of her being a lesbian will occasionally surface, often due to reflecting issues such as internalised lesbophobia or heteronormativity.
Documenting
Every year, GLAAD[1] releases their Where We Are On TV report, documenting the representation efforts of TV shows and allowing both the general public and fans to reflect on their media.
Own Voices
Fandom
Subcommunities
Queer Fandom encompasses a wide range of groups and people. Subcommunities relating to different sub-groups of the queer/LGBTQ+ community exist:
Specific Fandoms
Some fandoms are known for having a larger queer following than others, whether intentionally or not. Many of these are known to be key examples of queer media or an important part of queer fandom culture:
- It's A Sin
- Pose (TV series)
- She-Ra and the Princesses of Power
- Steven Universe
- Dead End: Paranormal Park
- Queer As Folk
- Outland
Meta
Written
- Queer Advocacy and Slash Fandom: Then and Now (2012-2013?) by lierdumoa - Multiple Fandoms
- Queer and Disturbing - A Dispatch from the Tolkien Fandom (July 2003) by tyellas - Tolkienverse
- On Canon, Authorial Authority, and Queer Representation (January 2013) by idvo - Multiple Fandoms
- Star Wars, queer representation and the mainstreaming of slash by Elizabeth Minkel - Star Wars
- The Revolutionary Power Of Fanfiction For Queer Youth by Jane Hu - General Fandom
- Life, But Not As We Know It: Star Trek, fan culture, slash fiction and the queering of Starfleet Command - (July 2020) by Geoff Allshorn - Star Trek, science fiction, fandom
- From Queer to Eternity - (November 2020) by Geoff Allshorn - Multiple fandoms
Presentations
- Don’t Like, Don’t Read: A Queer History of Fandom (2016) by Kitsune Heart - Multiple Fandoms
Audio
- BiPositive: Queerdom: How Fandoms Help Develop Queer Identities (2018) by Mari and MD - Multiple Fandoms
Video
- Slash Vidding: Editing and Media Representation (2018) by Lucia Gilbert - Multiple Fandoms
Communities & Websites
Websites
- Gay, Lesbian & Bisexual Characters on Star Trek - a 12-year saga of deceit, lies, excuses and broken promises - Star Trek
Livejournal
Blogs
Challenges
Fests
Prompt Memes
Mailing Lists
Events
Awards
Fan Clubs
Assimilation vs. Liberation
The issue around the politics of assimilation and liberation in relation to the LGBTQ+/Queer community is a complex one, and one that inevitably influences both the canon representation available, as well as the many ways in which queer fandom itself manifests.
- Assimiliation is the concept that queer folk should be accepted into the society as is, and encouraged to integrate into the dominant culture. Assimiliation is associated with more liberal or moderate positions.
- Liberation is the concept that queer folk should be accepted, but not in a way that forces queer culture and identity to be suppressed or played down, and in a way that doesn't attempt to appease the domiant culture, or does so at the expense of more marginalised members of the community. Liberation is associated with more leftist or radical positions, advocating for bigger, societal changes in order to ensure the freedom of queer folk.
The influence of queer politics, such as this, on fandom is numerous. Many fandoms with source materials produced by and for the mainstream, such as the MCU or Star Wars, are often likely to include representation that leans towards assimilation, rather than liberation. Some fans will argue that much of the canon media representation is often designed to be palatable to the normative structures of society.
However there are many nuances to this issue, least of all due to the Western centred narrative regarding both queerness and fandom, and the influence that has on many of the discussions had.
Intersectionality
Intersectionality is a term coined and developed by Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw to refer to the ways in which different identities and axes of oppression interlink and overlap with each other.
As it applies to fandom, and specifically queer fandom, many fans have pointed out some of the ways in which oppression and systemic bigotry affect the ways in which queer fans interact with fandom, and the struggles existing in these spaces. For example:
- Fandom preferances for white queerness rather than the queerness of POC, and some of the alienation that comes from that.
- Infiltration of TERFs into fandom spaces and the effects on trans fans.
Representation Issues
Queerbaiting
Bury Your Gays
2016
Current Patterns
Cancelled Shows
Surreal Canonisation
Updated Queerbaiting
Fanworks
Fanfiction
- Prevailing Winds (2008 to ?) by fawatson
Fanvids
Zines
- Queerness on New Planets - by Ellen Welsh - Ursula K. Le Guin
- LGBTQ+ Ships Zine - a multifandom anthology zine (2020)
- Sunshine through the Clouds - a DC Comics charity anthology, dedicated to celebrating the canon LGBT+ characters in DC Comics (2022)
- Diverse Universe - Australian queer SF club newsletter/zine (1999 -2009)
- Solar Spectrum - Australian anthology zine (2001 - 2002)
Fanart
'Queer as Fuck' in circular Gallifreyan by Conlang Calligraph (Doctor Who)
- Total Drama Pride Month Collab, a collaborative effort in Total Drama fandom to draw fanart featuring queer headcanons of every significant Total Drama character (110~ total.)
Recs
See Also
- Queer-coding
- Queerbaiting
- Transfic
- Homoerotic Subtext and TPTB
- Queer Het
- Genderfuck
- Crossdressing
- Stage Gay
- Woke Up Gay
- List of LGBTQ-Focused Conventions
Resources/External Links
- LGBTQ Character - Ao3 tag
- Queer Character - Ao3 tag
Related Concepts, Fandoms, Terms, Fanworks | |
See also | Lists of LGBT fictional characters • List of media portrayals of bisexuality • Media portrayal of lesbianism |