American Girl

From Fanlore
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Name: American Girl
Creator: Pleasant Rowland, Pleasant Company, Mattel
Date(s): 1986–present
Medium: books, dolls, movies
Country of Origin: United States
External Links: Official Website, Wikipedia
Click here for related articles on Fanlore.

American Girl is a line of dolls and books about various American girls throughout the ages with all types of backgrounds. In the 2000s, films began being developed starring their characters.


Each character has their own series of six books and collection of doll clothes and toys.

BeForever Characters

Originally known as The American Girls Collection or colloquially Historical Characters:

Girl of the Year dolls

Various girls/dolls were then presented each year from 2001 to the present besides 2002 due to the lack of sales.


This article or section needs expansion.

Although each doll/girl has its own series of books and doll line (or even a film), most of the archives combine the franchise under "American Girl". Fanfiction and other fanworks are more rare for the fandom, much like for Barbie since many people mainly interact with them at a young age and playing with them with their friends or collecting them. Fanfiction for the series didn't appear on FanFiction.Net until 2005, after Felicity's film was released, and in 2009(?) on Archive of Our Own. American Girl is a Yuletide fandom.

Crossovers are fairly rare, but due to fact that many of these girls take place in various years that many fandoms take place in makes it possible to have the potential for crossovers. For example, That's Not Her Name by forthosebelow crosses the Captain America Movieverse with an adult Kit Kittredge for a Kit/Steve Rogers pairing.

The majority of American Girl fandom is non-transformative, instead presenting as a collection fandom due to the limited nature of some of its products and the expense of the dolls leading to their being generally regarded as collectibles. However, there is a transformative fandom presence on Tumblr, where users mainly write meta and headcanon the historical girls as neurodivergent and LGBT. There is an Incorrect Quotes blog for American Girl.


Various gen and OC works are also created.


The fandom has seen a surprising amount of drama over the following issues:

  • Original Pleasant Company models vs Mattel versions
  • The company retiring fan favorites or less popular dolls
  • Historical accuracy
  • Adult content
  • Social justice matters

The community AG Over 18 was created in response to what a few fans felt was an overly puritanical approach to the fandom as well as a lack of fan content aside from costumes and accessories. [1] AG Over 18 was a place for all the fan-created content the forums and message boards discouraged or outright banned, from same-sex shipping to porn to gothic or villainous costumes made for dolls.

One of the founders of AG Over 18, Nethilia, has been involved in various social justice arguments on her blog and on other fandom spaces, mainly centered around her heated criticisms of not only the American Girl company for their perceived racism in creating new dolls but other fans' personal tastes. [2] She and one of her friends are known for being extremely harsh on anyone who publicly disagreed with Nethilia, going so far as to suicide bait one particular commenter who refused to back down. [3]

She ended up banned from the community after some personal drama with another mod, though this was eventually reversed with the other mod stepping down. [4]


Examples Wanted: Editors are encouraged to add more examples or a wider variety of examples.




Archives & Fannish Links

LiveJournal Communities

Other communities