Stan

From Fanlore
(Redirected from Stanning)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Synonyms: fan, stannie, standom
See also: Groupie, Super Fan, Fandom Nickname, OTC, sasaeng, Fan Army, K-Pop Stan Twitter, Actor Fan
Click here for related articles on Fanlore.

Stan means an obsessive fan. It is the name of an obsessed fan in the 2000 Eminem song of the same name.[1][2] The term has evolved and is also a verb, as in "I stan (for) X";[3] to stan is to be an obsessive fan. Stan has also become a more widely used term replacing "fan" in some fandoms circa 2020, such as MCYT where anyone who likes a specific creator can be called a "stan," even if they're not obsessive. Thus, usage also varies across fandom.

"Stan" is often given the folk etymology of being a portmanteau of "stalker" and "fan", but this appears coincidental -- Eminem was simply looking for a trisyllabic compound rhyme with consonance ("(your) biggest fan/this is Stan" -- note the way the "st" sound is used in both halves of the rhyme).

Note that "stan" (with a lower case s) is a nonspecific extreme fan, but "Stan" (with a capital S) is the Fandom Nickname for an Eminem fan, regardless of level of toxicity or obsession (although, considering the provenance of the word, a degree of self-deprecation is implied that makes it uncommon for casual Eminem fans to identify as Stans).

"(...)However, the first recorded mentions of stan behaviour was when Hungarian pianist and composer from the 19th century, Franz Liszt, gained heavy and rapid exposure, creating Lisztomania or Liszt fever. Hip hop artist Nas had also brought the term up in his song ‘Ether’ that was released in 2001. Since then, the word started to spread especially amongst online dwellers; forums, fan clubs and media soon adopted the word and slowly making it synonymous with fandoms."

The origin of stan cultureThe origin of stan culture — The Finery Report, Archived version

"(...)It’s not necessarily a new phenomenon. If you think of Beatlemania, that was a form of Stan culture. But the difference now is you’re all online and the majority of this takes place online.” (...)“In the last few years there’s been a number of instances in which pop stars and their fans have kind of organised en masse to do some kind of positive things, like get their single to up to the top of the charts, or negative things, which is what we’re seeing more recently, which is bombard and harass journalists over what seem to be negative reviews.”

Jules LeFevre, music editor of Junkee.com in AustraliaThe dark side of Stan culture, Archived version

It is commonly heard on ONTD (OH NO THEY DIDN'T), a LiveJournal community for celebrity gossip, and may have originated there.

The term appears in many fandoms. It is particularly common in fandoms for celebrities and real people, and is now strongly associated with K-pop and Twitter – see K-Pop Stan Twitter.

On LiveJournal anon memes the term is often applied to fans who display a loyalty or interest in other fans. Saying that someone is a [fan name]stan implies a level of partisan support of the fan in question that goes beyond merely liking their fic.

Stan Culture, Cancel Culture and toxic fandom

The term has become more widely used in the mainstream in recent years. It is extremely common for fans of singers and musicians to use the term. In many fandoms and media, the stan culture is considered as toxic.

"(...)Donating widely to charities and boosting information about the Black Lives Matter movement are uncomplicated, unmixed blessings, the kind of inspirational causes that the internet should rally around more often.

But the problem arises when we ignore the history of modern standom, and how frequently stans have rallied themselves around other, much less admirable causes.

Too frequently in the past, stans have perpetuated the worst of cancel culture. They have made systemic issues into personal ones; attempted to solve complex problems by bullying individuals off Twitter, and tried to ruin people’s lives. They rarely demonstrate any understanding of forgiveness or personal transformation. They have been thin-skinned. They have shouted down anyone who has tried to attack their idols. And they have spread rumours and falsehoods."

Stop Celebrating Stan Culture. It's Toxic., Archived version

"(...)Fan behaviours have moved from public spaces to online ones. Networks now are semi-permanent and easier for anyone to join and use. The speed at which interactions happen is more intense than ever; you can tweet in an instant. We now see fans and stans as obstinately present, and the anonymous, more colourful or aggressive sides of fan emotions are fully on display. When they act as is deemed inappropriate by people outside of the fanbase, the details are more visible, their behaviours easier to point fingers at en masse. If we should police stan culture, how do you temper something that’s built inherently into the fibre of not just fandom, but music culture itself? Stan has become shorthand for extreme or dangerous fans, and despite there being very dark sides to fandoms, I don’t think it should be a dirty word.

Stan culture is as old as pop music itself, Archived version

"(...)However, there are negative perceptions associated with being a stan, which originated from ‘fanwars’ and a stan’s overprotectiveness over their idols. These happen when stans start arguing with stans of different artists who are either perceived as rivals, have somehow offended them, or have been proven (or in some cases, ‘believed’) to be problematic in general. Fanwars also occur when stans are trying to defend their faves during a controversy or scandal involving their faves.

The negative connotation of the word stan, although often deemed unfair, was not unfounded. Over the years, stans’ influence and power have been increasing significantly, partly due to the support from their faves, even when their stans behave morbidly and start attacking people left and right.

For example, Game of Thrones fans were rather upset with how season eight of the show progressed. They went as far as to start a petition to remake season eight “with competent writers,” which received over 1.7 million signatures.

Stans, when defending their faves, will sometimes regress to being insensitive bullies, and their criticisms morphed into death threats.

Huffington Post wrote that Toronto freelance writer Wanna Thompson, who often writes about hip-hop, discovered this over the summer when she wrote a tweet that was mildly critical of Nicki Minaj's music. The responses from the rapper's fans weren't musical or cultural comments; they weren't well-reasoned arguments. They were straight-up insults and harassment directed to her not just on Twitter but also on Facebook, on Instagram, by email, and to her personal email. Some included photos of her four-year-old daughter. Others told her to kill herself. The rapper herself even joined in.

Star Wars stans, which could be seen as one of the biggest movie franchise stans, post and flooded Kelly Marie Tran with so much hate. They post racist and abusive comments, prompting her to leave social media for good after enduring months of harassment."

The origin of stan culture — The Finery Report, Archived version

"(...)Stan culture has encouraged fans to obsess over celebrities and it’s given them a sense of entitlement towards them. For some reason, it seems like stans feel a sense of ownership about their chosen celebrity and it’s disturbing. Unfortunately, these obsessions have led to real violence. Singer and Youtuber Christina Grimmie who appeared on ‘The Voice’ was murdered by a crazed fan during a meet-and-greet after a concert in 2016. On the other side, stans are developing unhealthy attachments to celebrities which fuel toxic behavior. They’ve formed their own communities where they discuss the object of their affection and attack other celebrities and their fanbases. Justin Bieber has the “Beliebers,” Taylor Swift has the “Swifties,” Nicki Minaj has the “Barbz” and there are countless more for different celebrities."

Stan culture is unhealthy for celebrities and fans by Shelby Stevens

Meta & Further Reading

On October 5, 2011 the New York Times posted an article defining and describing stans.[4][5]

References

  1. ^ Kpop Secrets! - what does stan mean?, tumblr post on 16 May 2010. (Accessed July 16, 2010)
  2. ^ See: Wikipedia:Stan (song)
  3. ^ https://www.fansplaining.com/episodes/101-stan-culture
  4. ^ NYTimes, Scratching the Celebrity Itch “Stans are a built-in support system,” said Tamar Anitai, the managing editor of MTV’s Web site. “They are very much aware of how the public sees this person, and they are here to protect him or her.” Posted October 5, 2011. Last accessed October 19, 2011.
  5. ^ ONTD, NYT writes about stans. No, they really do. lol this is a respected newspaper? how bored do you have to be to write an article on stanning anyway jfc. Posted October 5, 2011. Last accessed October 19, 2011.
Retrieved from "https://fanlore.org/w/index.php?title=Stan&oldid=2693080"