Hermione/Pansy
| Pairing | |
|---|---|
| Pairing: | Hermione Granger/Pansy Parkinson |
| Alternative name(s): | Pansmione, Panmione, Pansymione, Hermansy, Permione, Hermione/Pansy, Hr/P, HG/PP, H.M.S. Pug and Chipmunk |
| Gender category: | femslash, f/f |
| Fandom: | Harry Potter |
| Canonical?: | no |
| Prevalence: | uncommon overall, common for femslash |
| Archives: | |
| Other: | |
| Click here for related articles on Fanlore. | |
Hermione/Pansy is a Harry Potter femslash pairing involving Hermione Granger and Pansy Parkinson.
Madam Hooch's Broom Closet stated in early 2003 that the pairing was "decreasing in popularity",[1] but removed this sentence after the release of Order of the Phoenix. Their later description of the ship stated:
- "Ah, Hermione/Pansy. Bring on the angst. Often written to mirror the ever-popular Harry/Draco ship. A high proportion of the more dysfunctional and/or violent f/f romances feature this pairing."[2]
Hermione/Pansy tends to rank third or fourth in popularity among all Harry Potter femslash ships.[3][4] It is the most popular femslash pairing for Pansy, although Ginny/Pansy is also popular.[5][6]
As of 2021, Hermione/Pansy is the most popular ship for Pansy on Archive of Our Own (dwarfing her next popular ship, Draco/Pansy, nearly 2-to-1), and it is unusual for a femslash ship to be the most popular ship for a character.
Terminology
- H.M.S. Pug and Chipmunk is a ship name for the pairing popularized by FictionAlley Park's SCUSA forum. The name comes from the fact that Pansy is repeatedly described as "pug-faced" in the books and Pansy once compared Hermione's appearance to a chipmunk.[7]
- HG/PP usually stands for Hermione/Pansy, but it is ambiguous: it can also mean Hermione paired with Parvati Patil, Padma Patil, Peter Pettigrew, Piers Polkiss, or even Poppy Pomfrey. Hr/P nearly always refers to Hermione/Pansy.
- Pansmione is the preferred portmanteau for the pairing, popular on Tumblr. Permione is sometimes used as an alternative, but appears to be used more frequently for Hermione/Percy.[8]
Racism Controversy
In December 2021, popular fanartist UptheHill, a self-described Pansmione shipper, posted: I want to discuss Pansy, writing: "Regardless of what headcanons anyone might come up with, canon Pansy IS an awful, racist, hateful person exhibiting almost zero redeeming qualities. I mean, she WAS sympathetic to her friends, like Draco, but they were all awful people so it’s not much of an argument. She’s a bully, period. (And if anyone is unclear about how Pansy has exhibited racism, she basically called Angelina’s afro braids to look like “worms coming out of [her] head”). Since Hermione is now commonly portrayed as black/POC now - by me, too - pairing her with Pansy gets extra tricky and raises issues."
Others responded questioning the focus on Pansmione as a ship. "It always amazes me how male characters always get their redemption arc but female characters never do" (Teacup-Tai, 2021). "i feel like, in practice, most people ONLY bring up canon pansy’s racism as a reason not to ship pansmione, and that feels like taking a serious quandary and cheapening it with bias and shipwars" (Anon, 2021).
While Pansy is commonly depicted in fanon as being East Asian (see Racebending in Harry Potter), some have issue with that as the character is canonically anti-Black. "Just saw a post headcanoning Pansy Parkinson, a known racist, as a WOC. DAY RUINED" (HPNerdyHobbies, 2020).
Example Fanworks
Fan Fiction
- Like Music by nightfalltwen
- Trick Step by articcat621
- Cool Walls, Warm Thighs by thusspakekate
- Pansy, Rows, and Mutual Wanking by hpwlwbb, kysprite, violetclarity.
- a red rose grew up out of ice frozen ground by piesofrage
Fan Videos
Meta
- More Pansmione cause obviously there’s not enough in the world, Archived version by creepyasparagus on tumblr.
Art Gallery
Links & Resources
Hermione/Pansy Communities
- pansy_hermione at LiveJournal
- HermionePansy at Yahoo! Groups
- Pansy_and_Hermione at Yahoo! Groups
- Pansy-x-Hermione at DeviantArt
- pansmione-ship at Tumblr
Fanwork Resources
- Hermione Granger/Pansy Parkinson tag at Archive of Our Own
- [Hermione G., Pansy P.] pairing filter and Hermione G. & Pansy P. filter at FanFiction.Net
- Hermione/Pansy category at Adult-FanFiction.org
- Pansy/Hermione category at hpfanfiction.org (French)
- pairing: hermione/pansy tag at hp_girlslash
- Hermione Granger/Pansy Parkinson memories and p: hermione granger/pansy parkinson tag at crack_broom
- Pansy Parkinson/Hermione Granger fic listing at FictionAlley Park
Discussion & General Resources
- H.M.S. Pug and Chipmunk - Pansy/Hermione at FictionAlley Park's SCUSA forum
- hermione-x-pansy and pansmione tags on Tumblr
References
- ^ Anna Maria for Madam Hooch's Broom Closet, Femmeslash Ships: "Decreasing in popularity, but there are some good Hr/P fics out there. Often written to mirror the ever-popular Harry/Draco ship." Archived 13 March 2003 by the Wayback Machine.
- ^ Anna Maria for Madam Hooch's Broom Closet, Femmeslash Ships, last archived by the Wayback Machine on 23 October 2007.
- ^ It is the fourth-most popular pairing on hp_girlslash, a LiveJournal community founded in March 2003. According to the hp_girlslash community tags. Tags were introduced on LiveJournal in June 2005, but were added to older posts in the community (see the oldest posts tagged pairing: hermione/pansy). As of 01 April 2017, there are 198 posts tagged Hermione/Pansy, although at one point there may have been 220+ posts with the tag (see tag counts from February 2013). Compare 484 posts tagged Ginny/Hermione, 331 posts tagged Fleur/Hermione, 237 posts tagged Ginny/Luna, and 161 posts tagged Ginny/Pansy as of 01 April 2017.
- ^ On Archive of Our Own, founded in 2008, Hermione/Pansy is the third-most popular HP femslash ship, behind Ginny/Luna and Hermione/Ginny: Hermione Granger/Pansy Parkinson tag at AO3, 299 works as of 01 April 2017. Compare 587 works tagged Ginny/Luna, 374 works tagged Hermione/Ginny, and 234 works tagged Hermione/Luna.
- ^ On Archive of Our Own, Hermione/Pansy is the second-most popular Pansy pairing overall, behind Draco/Pansy and closely followed by Ron/Pansy and Harry/Pansy: 299 works tagged Hermione/Pansy, compared to 402 works tagged Draco/Pansy, 287 works tagged Ron/Pansy, 269 works tagged Harry/Pansy, and 183 works tagged Ginny/Pansy.
- ^ At the Pansy archive Pink Frilly Robes, Hermione/Pansy was the most popular femslash pairing and fourth-most popular Pansy pairing overall. In April 2013, there were 31 works in the Hermione/Pansy category, compared to 99 works in the Draco/Pansy category, 87 works in the Harry/Pansy category, 39 works in the Ron/Pansy category, and 26 works in the Ginny/Pansy category.
- ^ J. K. Rowling, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Chapter 19: "The Hungarian Horntail" (2000): "Stunningly pretty? Her?" Pansy Parkinson had shrieked the first time she had come face to face with Hermione after Rita's article had appeared. "What was she judging against—a chipmunk?
- ^ See permione tag on Tumblr.