The Course of Honour
|Name:||The Course of Honour|
|Date(s):||02 February 2017 - 15 May 2017|
|Medium:||formerly online at AO3|
|Country of Origin:|
|External Links:||archived on AO3|
|Click here for related articles on Fanlore.|
The small fandom has struggled to connect on AO3 because the tag wranglers have synned fandom tag "The Course of Honour - Avoliot" with the "Original Works" fandom tag where The Course of Honour was originally posted. The author does not read fanfiction of their own work because they feel it would be an intrusion on fannish spaces, which are usually author-free. Several works were written for the 2017 Yuletide exchange and it has since been occasionally requested in other exchange fandom events.
The Course of Honour and A Short Speech were taken down from Archive of Our Own on April 15th, 2019. Avoliot announced the takedown in advance, saying "It is likely to be available in some form or another in the future, but I can’t give any certainty as to what form," and encouraged fans to save the story by using AO3's download function. Before the takedown, the work had over 3900 kudos and over 1400 bookmarks.
In August 2019 it was announced that The Course of Honour was being published as a novel Tor Books, now titled Winter's Orbit. Debut author Everina Maxwell received a three-book deal.
When Jainan arrived on Iskat to represent his home planet in a diplomatic marriage to Imperial Prince Taam, he was naïve enough to hope the match would work. Taam knew better. Five years later, his confidence shattered, Jainan is released when Taam dies in an accident, only to be faced with another marriage to help salvage his treaty. Jainan understands how the real world works now; but Prince Kiem - the cheerful, scandal-prone darling of the Iskat celebrity magazines - keeps breaking all the rules he's learned.
Jainan, an off-planet diplomat, arrived at court five years ago to marry Prince Taam. When Prince Taam dies in an accident, Jainan is quickly forced into marriage with another minor royal to keep his treaty valid. Jainan is shattered from five years of a bad marriage and knows hes going to fail at making his new one work, but his new partner, Prince Kiem, is Taams opposite in most ways. Jainan isnt quite sure how to deal with this.
In late May of 2016, all of the previously posted pieces of the "Arranged marriage space royalty origfic" were collected in a comment thread the on-going WIP post fail-fandomanon. Six parts were posted immediately, followed by another ten parts. The last part posted to FFA was part 17 on September 30th, 2016 and in an early February comment on the same section Avoliot (posting anonymously) told a fellow anon: "It's all done, it's 70% edited, and it's going to my beta next Monday come hell or high water. Depending on how long it takes her to beta and me to fix 100k, if you check back in a few weeks it may be up? I will be putting a link here and probably leaving a main meme comment." Roughly a week later, Aviolot switched to Archive of Our Own.
Avoliot created a Course of Honour Updates tumblr.
[The Course of Honour is] not fanwork in that it's based on anyone's intellectual property, but TBH a lot of it reads like a lot of fanfic for fandoms I'm not in - it has the same "the author's primary interest here is the tropes/kinks" feel, the same missing characterization... essentially, the same focus on what the author gets off on and lack of content that readers who don't get off on that might find interesting.
Controversy and Wank
Miswrangling by AO3
- For more depth on this see the AO3 Original Works and Self-Pub Wrangling Debacle
On August 26th, 2017, an anonymous user posted to fail_fandomanon's AO3 thread asking for advice on what to say to AO3 support to convince them to unsynn "The Course of Honour - Avoliot" from "Original Works."
I wrote to AO3 support because the Course of Honour fanfics (Is The New Prince K Here To Stay?: http://archiveofourown.org/works/11410209 & And Indeed There Will Be Time: http://archiveofourown.org/works/11026398) were synned to original works two weeks age, and today I got their reply.I think the rationale is a bit unconvincing, because afaik 17776 is published on Internet only and hardly qualifies as published pre-existing canon under the same standard, but it still has its own fandom tag. I also doesn't see any proof that the two fanfics are "a cooperative attempt to build a canon" instead of "fanworks of an existing canon". However, I'm not very good at formulating convincing arguments. What do you think, nonnies?)
Thanks for asking about this fandom. I passed this question on to the wranglers. After considering the tag and reviewing the works and the lack of a clearly published source material, the Wranglers don't feel that the fandom tag should be canonized at this time. They note that they very very rarely canonize a fandom that is not based on a published pre-existing canon. Even then, it requires a significant number of discrete creators. As these are not fanworks of an existing canon, but a cooperative attempt to build a canon, that it is better sorted under "Original Works". They recommend using a common Additional Tag to simplify searching.
With help from anonymous users on fail_fandomanon, the anon in contact with AO3 support wrote back the following:
I find the argument unsatisfactory and worrying.
The Course of Honour is a self-contained, single-author canon and not a collaborative work. Any stories using the characters or setting from it authored by others are thus fanfiction and not additions to the canon itself no matter how much the fic writer may have discussed the canon with the author. Any argument to the contrary actually sets a distressing number of bad precedents because it's purporting to give ownership of the canon to people other than the original creator. By denying that there is one original creator and pretending that it's a group project, AO3 fails to acknowledge the original author's intellectual property rights.
As the original creator has never listed these other people as their co-writers or stating that it's a deliberate group project, it is wrong to list the works in question as "a cooperative attempt to build a canon." as even the writer of the works in question explicitly list them as fanfic. This decision puts all fanfics of an original work on the same canonicity level, and that's misleading and frustrating for creators and readers alike.I would like AO3 to reconsider this decision based on the above reasons.
On September 9th, 2017, the anon returned with a reply from AO3 Support:
I apologize for the lack of clarity in my response. The wranglers' concern is not whether a work is "collaborative" or not, and my inclusion of that word was a mistake on my part.Their evaluation was based on the fact that the creator's source canon is posted on an inherently fannish site. As such, they consider it to be an original fannish work. I have passed on your additional feedback, but they are not changing the wrangling at this time.
Both pieces mentioned in the original August post were written by emilyenrose, who beta read The Course of Honour for Avoliot and is thanked in the first author's note of the work. They were posted earlier in the year and in August of 2017 were the only TCoH fanworks on the archive. A third work by another author was added in October of 2017, and more since then, but the fandom tag is still synned to "Original Work" as of mid-2019. With the help of Aviolot, fans have been trying to make each other aware of the tagging problems, for example in this tumblr exchange:
[Excerpt from Aviolot's post "Course of Honour & Fic"]
1. For anyone who wants CoH fic: I know there are a couple on Ao3! I don’t think ‘Course of Honour’ is very unique so maybe try plugging a character name into the search box.
2. For anyone who wrote fic: I don’t know if this is helpful for listing but I know there is a fan comm - I don’t think it’s particularly active because super tiny fandom, but it may be a place to put links?
Original works posted to "fannish spaces" are generally said to be disallowed from the yearly winter fanwork exchange Yuletide, mostly because the author has identified the work as fannish in some nature and might expect the same social etiquette around further transformation that authors of fanworks would expect.
The third post on the 2017 Fandom Eligibility post was a fan asking if The Course of Honour would be eligible. They provided a link to the author's blanket statement of permission for fanworks. A mod replied:
While in the past we have ruled out any work posted to AO3, we are willing to trial an exception this year for original works.We would appreciate you making a comment on the Evidence Post when you nominate it, to sum up what the fandom is and why it stands alone.
In the anon meme yuletide_coal, the discussion during sign-ups of The Course of Honour's likely inclusion was 89 comments long. Much wank ensued over whether The Course of Honour is a fanwork because of the AO3 Terms of Service and if that should automatically disqualify it from Yuletide. There were accusations of Avoliot trying to cause drama to stir up interest on anon probably because the anons in question were unaware that much of The Course of Honour's initial fanbase grew organically from fail_fandomanon.
- Cultural Misunderstandings by antonomasia09
- Fundamental Theorems by blue_spruce
- Is The New Prince K Here To Stay? by emilyenrose
- And Indeed There Will Be Time by emilyenrose
- Blanket of Stone by lurknomoar
- The Ghosts Will Try to Find You by lizzieonawhim
- An Etching of Love by KathrynNolan86
- Misunderstandings by Eluvia
- Jainan and Kiem + Jainan in hospital by nevenne-creates
- "The Course of Honour - Avoliot" fandom tag on AO3 (synned with "Original Works")
- "Course of Honour" OR "Course of Honor" search that actually produces all the fanworks plus the canon material on AO3.
- Course of Honour Fandom Unite a collection of TCoH fanfiction on AO3.
- Course of Honour tag on Avoliot's tumblr.
- The Course of Honour tag on tumblr
- courseofhonourfics on Dreamwidth
- Avoliot, response to an anonymous ask on 15 October 2017. (Accessed 31 July 2018.)
- Aviolot, Course of Honour & Fic. Posted August 15th, 2018. Archived.
- For example, the 2019 Pining Exchange; see the nominated tags in the tagset under "Other Media", the single request on this page, and the sign up summary where it shows one person requested it and two people offered it.
- 2019.03.25 by avoliot
- archived on WBM, March 28 2019
- Announcing Winter’s Orbit, a Queer Romantic Space Opera Debut, Aug 13, 2019
- The Couse of Honour on AO3 (Accessed 31 July 2017.)
- The earliest available on dememe.info (fail_fandomanon's searchable database) is a WIP post from April 26th but comments on it indicate that there was more before then and the author's numbering of subsequent posts on the subthread in FFA's WIP post implies it's missing the first part.
- Avoliot, posting anonymously, on a WIP post from April 26th. Accessed 05 August 2018.
- Avoliot, posting anonymously, on Arranged marriage space royalty origfic. Posted 30 September 2016. (Accessed 05 August 2018.)
- Avoliot, posting anonymously, on Arranged marriage space royalty origfic. Posted 06 February 2017. (Accessed 05 August 2018.)
- Avoliot, posting anonymously, on Arranged marriage space royalty origfic. Posted 15 February 2017. (Accessed 05 August 2018.)
- Anonymous on yuletide-coal on 05 September 2017. (Accessed 05 August 2018.)
- Anonymous on yuletide-coal on 05 September 2017. (Accessed 05 August 2018.)
- Re: Archive of Our Own [AO3 thread] - The Course Of Honour fic synned to Original posted by anonymous on fail_fandomanon on 26 August 2018. (Accessed 31 July 2018.)
- New reply from AO3 support on The Course of Honour fanfic tag syn posted by anonymous on fail_fandomanon on 02 Septemper 2018. (Accessed 31 July 2018.)
- antonomasia09, reblog here. August 31st, 2018. Archived. It was reblogged by Aviolot the next day here.
- morbane, September 3rd, 2017, in Fandom Eligability for 2017.
- Various anons on yuletide_coal posted 04 September 2017 through 10 September 2017. (Accessed 05 August 2018.)
- Anonymous on yuletide-coal on 04 September 2017. (Accessed 05 August 2018.)
- Yuletide '17 requests, accessed August 4th, 2018
- Yuletide '18 requests, accessed August 4th, 2018