Fanlore:Featured Articles

From Fanlore
Jump to: navigation, search

Fanlore Featured Articles are articles spotlighted weekly on Fanlore's main page.

Featured Article Nomination Requirements

For an article to be considered a good Featured Article nomination, it should fit the following criteria:

  • It should follow Fanlore policies.
  • It should have a good first (or first two) paragraphs introducing the topic well. (This beginning is what's used to spotlight the article on the main page.)
  • The article shouldn't be flagged with {{Template:Stub}}, {{Template:ExpandArticle}}, or equivalent notices, or have headers with no content in them.
  • The article should be thorough and have a solid amount of information. The page should be up to date, or as up to date as it can reasonably be. There shouldn't be any glaring holes in the discussion of the article's subject, but the page does not need to be perfect or have every example/event associated with the topic.
  • It should also give enough context for a newcomer to understand the topic, and the significance of it in fandom. For examples of articles that provide enough context for a general reader, check out past Featured Articles.
  • It should not have been previously approved as a Featured Article and displayed on Fanlore's main page - though previously rejected articles are eligible to be re-nominated if improvements have been made. See Re-nomination.

Nomination Process

The nomination process is a three month voting period where editors evaluate articles nominated by other users, address any outstanding concerns, and approve or reject nominees.

Initial Nomination and Commenting Structure

Editors who identify a page that follows the criteria above should add it as a new section in Fanlore:Featured Article Nominations following this format:

=== [[Page title]] ===

Nominated by [[User:Username|]] on DATE. As of this writing, the page has a good intro and no content flags. 

(Add other comments here)

All editors are welcome to fix issues identified in nomination comments and report back. An editor does not need to vote or be the original nominator to add comments addressing an issue or concern. Editors are also encouraged to address their own suggestions, if possible.

Voting System

To be featured, a nominated article needs four affirmative votes and no outstanding issues. Everyone should bold the main word(s) in their vote—'yes,' 'no,' 'hesitant yes,' and so on—for easier tallying.

  • Affirmative votes are all variations on 'yes', with no caveat.
  • A 'hesitant yes' (also 'conditional yes' and 'yes, but') is considered a yes only once the voter's concerns have been addressed. 'Hesitant yes' should only be used if the voter clearly outlines actionable goals that can be addressed within the voting time period, with the knowledge that as long as their suggested edits are made, their vote counts in the affirmative.
  • 'Maybe' votes are contextually affirmative or negative depending on added comment and Staff discretion. (Please try to refrain from 'maybe' votes for clarity purposes.)
  • 'No', 'not yet' and 'maybe not' all count as negative votes. An article will bypass the three month voting period and be disqualified from the nomination process if it accumulates three negative votes. (This is solely to keep the nomination page from getting cluttered with articles that are clearly not ready to be featured, and not to be used as a non-negotiable rule.)

Some example votes with comments:

* '''Yes.''' That looks great! --~~~~
* '''Yes.''' Good one! --~~~~
* '''Hesitant yes.''' Maybe that intro could be fleshed out a bit more? It doesn't really explain much. --~~~~
* '''Not Yet.''' This is a good page, and with some hard work it could be featured, but right now it has some definite gaps, such as [examples]. -~~~~
* '''No.''' This needs more [[PPOV]]. --~~~~

Approval and Rejection

When the nomination reaches four affirmative votes with no serious objections, Fanlore staff will move the nominated article and subsequent discussion from the Featured Article nominations page to the relevant archive page, along with a notice of the outcome:

::'''Nomination approved.'''

Fanlore staff and gardeners, who regularly monitor both lists to make sure approved nominations are added to the list, will schedule featured articles (the next section has more information about this).

If within three months of the nomination date a nomination doesn't reach four votes or has serious objections that are not addressed, Fanlore staff and gardeners should archive the nomination with a notice:

::'''Nomination failed due to lack of votes.'''

In some cases (mostly too many negative votes, though occasionally if an article was already featured) a page can be removed from the nomination process before the three month period is up. Staff will archive these nominations with the notice:

::'''Nomination failed due to objections.'''

Re-nomination

Articles that have been previously nominated and rejected may be re-nominated if the page has been substantially improved and if the issues raised during the previous nomination have been addressed.

Articles that were previously approved (and thus already featured) are currently ineligible for renomination. Please remember to check the Fanlore Featured Articles category for the pages that were featured in each year before nominating a page.

Featured Article scheduling

Fanlore staff and gardeners should edit the Featured Article template for the upcoming month at least once a month, listing the pages to be featured in the following four weeks. For more information on how to edit the Featured Article template, consult Template:Featured Article.


Featured Article
How To & About About Featured ArticlesHow to Nominate
Past Featured Articles 2020201920182017
Featured Article Nominations 2020201920182017