Talk:Nirvana (band)

From Fanlore
Jump to navigation Jump to search

This page could use some organization. --MPH (talk) 23:24, 7 May 2019 (UTC)

Featured Article Nomination comments

This article was nominated as a Featured Article in March 2021, and a number of points were raised during the nomination process about things that could use improving. I'm transferring these over to the Talk page so they can be easily referenced by future editors to this page; if anyone wants to re-nominate in future, it would be a good idea to make sure these points are addressed first. The full nomination discussion is archived on the 2021 Archive subpage. --enchantedsleeper (talk) 21:15, 30 May 2021 (UTC)

  • "There is a [citation needed] on the page down at the bottom and in general for such a prominent band I feel like there's a real lack of references, especially for a lot of the stuff in the "common tropes" section"
  • "I feel like it is missing information about the fandom in the 1990s itself, I remember being a teen in the early 1990s, and even though I personally wasn't a fan, I knew Nirvana was hugely popular, like I remember girls making their own t-shirts, or having a binders decorated with pictures of Kurt Cobain, etc, and this was in a rural area of Ontario, Canada. I know a lot of this is hard to track pre-world wide web, and maybe not possible to source, but I thought I should mention it."
  • "There isn't a fandom section, with an intro to the fandom. I also remember there been increased fan activity on the anniversary of Kurts death, but a lot of that was pre-internet with IRL friends. (I had a poster of Kurt over my bed during my teeny years) I do think the conspiracy theory section shouldn't make generalisations based on gender, and I'd be ok with seeing the citation needed bit removed."
  • "I feel the Courtney Love/Conspiracy theories (Fan theories?) section could be fleshed out a bit?"