Silk and Flannel

From Fanlore
Jump to navigation Jump to search

You may be looking for Silk, a K/S story.

Zine
Title: Silk and Flannel
Publisher: Agent With Style
Editor(s):
Date(s): 2002-2003
Series?:
Medium: print
Size:
Genre:
Fandom: Smallville
Language: English
External Links:
Click here for related articles on Fanlore.
cover issue #1, Kate Nuernberg

Silk and Flannel is a slash anthology.

Issue 1

Silk and Flannel 1 was published in 2002 and contains 217 pages. Cover art by Kate Nuernberg and black and white interior photo-manips by Henry Jones, Jr.

Artwork

Reactions and Reviews: Issue 1

Decent layout, decent editing, not too bad on the technical writing, but the stories are just average. Nothing special to stand out and make it worth buying the zine, either with the stories or the format. It's much better to wait for these to be published online. [1]

Issue 2

cover of issue #2 by Kate Nuernberg

Silk and Flannel 2 was published in July 2003. It has 191 pages.

Artwork

Reactions and Reviews: Issue 2

When I buy a zine I darn well read every story in that zine because I've paid good money for it. That's my policy. I've followed it through mostly gen zines I bought for one slash story, through het zines, through multimedia ones featuring fandoms I knew nothing about, because I want my money's worth. This was the first zine I've read where I couldn't make myself stick to that policy. The format is fine, the screen caps in place of artwork are borderline okay and technically speaking there isn't much problem. It's the writing itself that made this such a painful experience and a real waste of my money. Every single story in this zine had OOC characterization. Some were worse than others and some were almost decent, but it was still pretty bad. Lex is cuddly and his IQ has drastically lowered, Jonathan Kent adores him, Clark is the Big Dumb Alien, Clark and Lex call each other cutsey nicknames and the writing gushes purple. The one story I held out hope for at the end of the zine (a continuation of an online series) made me cringe. It was just a huge disappointment. The "artwork" that I mentioned in the beginning is nothing more than plain, black and white screen caps, mostly with nothing at all done to them. While there isn't anything necessarily wrong with that, it's very plain and uninspiring. The few screencaps that do have captions on them all have punctuation errors, taking away from what could have been rather funny captions. This whole zine is a sad, sad thing and I highly recommend giving it a miss, even when the stories come online. [2]

References