Marks and Scars
| Fanfiction | |
|---|---|
| Title: | Marks and Scars |
| Author(s): | E H Smith |
| Date(s): | 28 October 2001 |
| Length: | 8177 words |
| Genre(s): | crossover, gen |
| Fandom(s): | Harry Potter, Vorkosigan |
| Relationship(s): | |
| External Links: | FictionAlley Marks and Scars on archive.org |
Click here for related articles on Fanlore. | |
Marks and Scars is a crossover between the Harry Potter and Vorkosigan universes by E H Smith, in which Severus Snape meets Mark Vorkosigan at Hogwarts. The author's summary is:
In which two of the most intriguing characters from the works of J.K. Rowling and Lois McMaster Bujold meet for tea and, eventually, sympathy. A meeting between these characters is certainly something their respective authors would never have anticipated, but their worlds turn out to be oddly congruent. Takes place during the spring of Harry's sixth year at Hogwarts (not that Harry figures in this story in any but the most peripheral way) and, from the Bujoldian point of view, during KOMARR.
One of the earliest crossovers published in the Vorkosiverse and the first to cross it with the HP universe, 'Marks and Scars' inspired stories in AJ Hall's Lust Over Pendle universe, particularly Time Shall Not Mend; AJ Hall writes:
The story is sometimes used to introduce HP fans to the Vorkosiverse. For example, prolific Bujold fanwriter Philomytha credits it (with 'Time Shall Not Mend') with introducing her to Bujold.[2]
There are two chaptered sequels, Without Enchantment (2001) and No Great Magic (2002).
Recs and Reviews
It has been recommended at Crack_Van[3] and by Templum Bellonae,[4] Philomytha[2] Melannen,[5] The RCK[6] and others.
This is an HP/Vorkosigan crossover, a trilogy of stories that deftly captures the flavor of both author voices, in addition to re-creting the mixture of humor and serious themes. (Raveninthewind at Crack_Van)[3]
If you haven't read the Vorkosigan books as well as HP, then you will be completely lost. I found this series interesting and warming. Two men, more Dark than not, but both working for the Light. They talk with perception and brilliance. Part two "Without Enchantment," REALLY understands the Vorkosigan family (I would like to be Cordelia when I grow up.) Part three, "No Great Magic," is just as perceptive and surprising.[7]
These are quite old and HP canon compliance is only through GoF. Severus Snape and Mark Vorkosigan actually have quite a bit in common, which becomes evident when they meet up despite the light-years and centuries that should make this impossible.[8]
References
- ^ Time Shall Not Mend (accessed 2 September 2015)
- ^ a b Philomytha: Favourite Vorkosigan fics (accessed 2 September 2015)
- ^ a b crack-van: Harry Potter/Vorkosigan Universe (PG-13) (accessed 2 September 2015)
- ^ Templum Bellonae: Marks and Scars (accessed 2 September 2015)
- ^ Melannen: Longfic recs for Stellar_dust (and anybody else who wants them) (accessed 2 September 2015)
- ^ Consensus Realities: Crossovers (accessed 3 September 2015)
- ^ "Marks and Scars, by E.H. Smith post to forums.darklordpotter.net March 11, 2008". Archived from the original on 2023-02-19.
- ^ "Friday recs: Snape crossovers". Archived from the original on 2023-02-19.