Talk:Supernatural/Gen Fanzines

Since the table is titled "Supernatural Gen and Het Fanzines List," should this page really be Supernatural/Gen and Het Fanzines?--Penknife 15:40, 22 August 2009 (UTC)

I actually think that the slash and gen fanzines subpages (with the c&p'ed tables) should be cleaned up into proper wiki-tables (that you can resort and such, like the one on the K/S zine page), and both put on a subpage Supernatural/Fanzines for consistency with other fandoms. Franky even as a large fandom today SPN doesn't have that many zines compared to say the classic trek, that I see a need to separate them onto pages. Then once the reformatting and transfer is done as cleanup this page could be deleted.--Ratcreature 15:50, 22 August 2009 (UTC)

both suggestions are good. I don't have the time/energy to reformat the data (remember I am also managing several other fanzine lists, volunteering on both the Star Wars and Star Trek fanzines list and tracking down more visual fanzine content for fanlore). So I'll toss this out and say: have at it. Morgan Dawn

I didn't mean to imply the orignal table contributor ought to do the work. *g* I've now reformatted the table into a wiki one on the fanzine page, wikified the titles and the publishers, but this page should probably stay up until all the individual zine series have their own pages, b/c I didn't include the summary info or all page numbers in the overview table, because that would have been too squished with that much text in the table.--Ratcreature 17:21, 22 August 2009 (UTC)

Thank you! And thank you for bringing up the subcategory issue - if you don;t hear back from Fanlore Gardeners, have at it....--Morgandawn

Like I said above, I transferred all of these in a proper wiki formatted table that's much easier to edit on Supernatural/Fanzines. Additions should be done there. I don't think anyone needs to bother to edit this. Also I don't think there are any het fanzines on this list, iirc.--Ratcreature 13:25, 11 September 2009 (UTC)

MD here: MD here - my suggestion is that (a) Gardeners move the summaries to each individual zine pages and then (b) either delete this page or turn it into some other type of wiki friendly "list of all SPN zines" with sortable tables. --Morgandawn 16:35, 27 January 2010 (UTC)