On Fanlore, users with accounts can edit pages including user pages, can create pages, and more. Any information you publish on a page or an edit summary will be accessible by the public and to Fanlore personnel. Because Fanlore is a wiki, information published on Fanlore will be publicly available forever, even if edited later. Be mindful when sharing personal information, including your religious or political views, health, racial background, country of origin, sexual identity and/or personal relationships. To learn more, check out our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Select "dismiss" to agree to these terms.
The Blake's 7 Q-study
| Fan Survey | |
|---|---|
| Title: | The Blake's 7 Q-study |
| Surveyor: | Una McCormack |
| Date(s): | 1998[1] |
| Medium: | online |
| Fandom(s): | Blake's 7 |
| External Links: | q-research.connectfree.co.uk/personal/b7qstudy.htm via WBM |
| Click here for related articles on Fanlore. | |
The Blake's 7 Q-study is a study of fans' appreciation of Blake's 7 episodes carried out by Una McCormack in 1998 and published at her website.
Methodology
This study used a technique called Q-methodology to explore the different ways in which Blake's 7 fans expressed their likes and dislikes, and the different understandings of the programme and what constitutes 'good' and 'bad' B7 which underpin these.[2]
Fans from Blake's 7 mailing lists and elsewhere were invited to rank the complete set of 52 episodes on a scale of +5 to –5, and were also asked to provide comments explaining their high & low ratings. A total of 29 responses were received. Responses were found to cluster into five different patterns, or accounts, each of which represents a different way of enjoying the show.[2]
The Five Accounts
Beautiful Suffering
[A] strong focus on character portrayal, often though not exclusively of Avon; the whole programme is viewed as a series of vignettes or character 'bites', which make most of the show enjoyable.[3]
- Highly ranked: 'Aftermath', 'Rumours of Death', 'Sarcophagus', 'Orbit', 'Blake'
- Poorly ranked: 'The Web', 'Animals', 'Cygnus Alpha', 'Volcano', 'Stardrive'
If You Were the Only Boy in the World...
[T]his account, in common with [Beautiful Suffering], places primacy on strong characterization across the cast. 'Character moments' are also enjoyed, across all characters. However, a great deal of emphasis is placed on Blake and, more particularly, on the Blake/Avon relationship, which is seen as pivotal to the series.[4]
- Highly ranked: 'The Way Back', 'Rumours of Death', 'Pressure Point', 'Star One', 'Terminal'
- Poorly ranked: 'Animals', 'Stardrive'
A Little Bit of Politics
[E]pisodes are seen primarily as self-contained units, and rewarded for being good or bad on their own terms, with much less emphasis on any over-arching continuity. Criteria include plot, dialogue & performances, with plots which deal with the politics of the series being favoured.[5]
- Highly ranked: 'Rumours of Death', 'Blake', 'Gambit', 'Games', 'Gold'
- Poorly ranked: 'Ultraworld', 'Animals', 'The Web', 'Dawn of the Gods', 'Headhunter'
Universal Constancy
[V]iews B7 as a continous narrative, in which particular episodes play an essential part in constructing. Consistency of the B7 universe is paramount, and the 'real' B7 is made up of seasons 1 and 2. Episodes which violate this internal narrative are strongly criticized and even completely dismissed.[6]
- Highly ranked: 'The Way Back', 'Star One', 'Mission to Destiny', 'City at the Edge of the World', 'Blake'
- Poorly ranked: 'Sarcophagus', 'Ultraworld', 'Voice from the Past', 'Power', 'Headhunter'
Carry on Up the Rebels!
[H]ugely enjoys aspects of B7 which are funny and camp, although there is also considerable enjoyment of the more poignant moments of the series. ... [E]njoys B7 on as many levels as it can possibly manage.[7]
- Highly ranked: 'Bounty', 'Sarcophagus', 'Aftermath', 'City at the Edge of the World', 'Sand'
- Poorly ranked: none stated
References
- ^ Lysator: Volume 98 : Issue 118: Research (accessed 24 September 2015)
- ^ Jump up to: a b The Blake's 7 Q-study (accessed 24 September 2015)
- ^ The Blake's 7 Q-study: Account 1 - Beautiful Suffering (accessed 24 September 2015)
- ^ The Blake's 7 Q-study: Account 2 - If You Were the Only Boy in the World... (accessed 24 September 2015)
- ^ The Blake's 7 Q-study: Account 3 - A Little Bit of Politics (accessed 24 September 2015)
- ^ The Blake's 7 Q-study: Account 4 - Universal Constancy (accessed 24 September 2015)
- ^ The Blake's 7 Q-study: Account 5 - Carry on Up the Rebels! (accessed 24 September 2015)