From Fanlore
Jump to: navigation, search
Name: Thanfiction
Alias(es): Victoria Bitter, VB, Amy Player, Jordan Wood, Mr Frodo, Voyagerbabe, Padawan Sidious, PadawanS, Strwriter, Chris the Marine, Rennie Gade, Andrew Blake, andythanfiction [1]
Type: fanwriter, fanartist
Fandoms: The Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, Supernatural, Due South, Star Trek: Voyager, Sharpe, Horatio Hornblower, Hunger Games
Communities: daydverse
URL: Lord of the Rings fan fic and art, archived link
Due South, Horatio Hornblower and Star Trek Voyager fan fic and art, archived
Lord of the Rings, Due South, and Horatio Hornblower fic on
Fandom Wank on VB
Click here for related articles on Fanlore.


Andy Blake, a.k.a. Thanfiction, is a fanwriter and fanartist best known for his involvement in a number of high-profile fandom controversies. He first joined Lord of the Rings fandom in the early 2000s as Victoria Bitter, and later went on to use a number of other pseuds.

For much more, see Victoria Bitter Wank.

Thanfiction's best-known fanfic is the Harry Potter epic Dumbledore's Army and the Year of Darkness, which has spawned an extensive shared universe called the DAYDverse.

In 2013, Thanfiction started participating in and writing meta on tumblr for the Supernatural fandom, in which Thanfiction ships Dean/Castiel and has organized fan meet-ups.

In February 2015, Aja Romano published an article on Blake that was extremely controversial. The article and the events that followed provoked a great deal of criticism from those interviewed for the article, and within fandom at large.

Main article: The Strange Lives of Andrew Blake


Thanfiction's FanFiction.Net bio, written in 2008 and updated in 2013:
Hi, I'm Thanfiction, short for stranger-than-fiction, also known as Andrew, a 30-year-old guy who has found himself in up to his pointed hat in the most out-of-control one-shot in the history of the wizarding world. If you want to know more about me, you can just ask, really. I'm a pretty open kinda bloke. I'm brash, opinionated, and a bit sharp-tongued at times, so consider yourself warned. I'm also an artist, doing a great deal of work in the HP fandom in a wide variety of styles and media, including many illustrations for my own fic. You can find all of my artwork [at DeviantArt], but please heed the tags when it comes to what is appropriate for what age of eyes. Ignore these, I'm not responsible for paying for your therapist. [...] UPDATE JULY 2, 2013: As you may have noticed, I've recently gotten into SPN fandom, specifically Destiel. Yes, I'm still doing the Daydverse, I'm still finishing AP. Life - including a nasty little triple homicide [2], three major moves, four job changes, and starting school - got in the way for a while, but I refuse to give up. A certain hunter and his angel may have wedged a place in my muse and heart, but the DA will always come first. [3]
Thanfiction's LiveJournal art page bio (2008?):
I'm Thanfiction, also known as Andrew, also known as Andy, also known as a 25 year old guy [4] new to fandom as of April '08. My interests are quite varied, I write fanfiction with extreme gusto and have strong opinions on most things, but all that is over here, on my LJ, which is friends-locked. What matters here is that I'm also a rather prolific artist. I take commissions not only willingly, but extremely eagerly, and have developed rather a specialty for rare pairings. I'll draw anything you want as long as it is between consenting human (or relatively human) adults and involves no bodily fluids not normally found in sex, and my rates and other niggly details are found below. You're welcome to peruse this journal and/or my Deviantart page, and I hope you are struck with the uncontrollable impulse to get that image of your favorite character, pairing, or moment out of your head and into your hands at last! [5]


Detailed Timelines

An Abridged Timeline

  • Early 2003: Jordan Wood a.k.a. misterfrodo joins Bit of Earth; Victoria Bitter is reported to have committed suicide. In February, Jordan Wood and Victoria Bitter are revealed to be the same person.
  • December 2003: Bit of Earth/Tentmoot fiasco; Amy Player is charged with identity theft and charity fraud
  • March 2007: Amy Player admits to being Strwriter, Voyagerbabe, Victoria Bitter, Mr. Frodo, and Jordan Wood;[13] claims to be leaving fandom for good.[14]
  • December 2009: Thanfiction is identified as the same person as Victoria Bitter (et al.).[15]
  • December 2013: Thanfiction announced a LARP event, "Supernatural Season Nine Finale Apocalarp", to be held in conjunction with Supernatural's season 9 finale, and based on canonical elements of the show's futuristic dystopia of episode 5x04 "The End".[16] This venture has received some criticism, with various people posting warnings of Thanfiction's previous fannish behaviour.[17][18]

Victoria Bitter

See Victoria Bitter Wank for descriptions of this fan's activities, including sockpuppets, fraud, and general mayhem and manipulation. And worse.

In December 2009, the Harry Potter fanfic writer and fanartist Andrew Blake was identified as Victoria Bitter [19] Prior to Victoria Bitter's entry into LOTR fandom, they wrote Due South and Star Trek Voyager fan fiction and made fan art under the name of Voyagerbabe.

Victoria Bitter initially contributed to The Lord of the Rings RPF fandom with well-received fic. Victoria Bitter (with then-partner OrangeBlossom) created numerous sockpuppets. Victoria Bitter claimed to be channeling Elijah Wood's spirit, and that JRR Tolkien's writing was based on historical fact, and was receiving Meriadoc Brandybuck's memories in a dream.

Victoria Bitter and OrangeBlossom defrauded the convention and their attendees by taking money for products and services they never meant to deliver, ruining the con in the process. Turimel, another member of, wrote a book about her experiences with Victoria Bitter. It was called When the Fan Hits the Shit. [20]

Victoria Bitter later faked suicide repeatedly.

Some Images

Further Reading

For much more, see Victoria Bitter Wank.


  1. these pseuds are linked or confirmed in a number of places, some of which are: tent moot crash - Had to share: I got my hush money, after all!; Archive, Spork Commentary on (Thanfiction) Amy Player’s “Apology Letter”; Archive, Andy Blake Timeline. Part 1; Andy Blake Timeline. Part II; Archive; Archive; Giving in at last; Archive
  2. Hate, extortion, lies underlie Fairfield murder-suicide, May 9, 2011; WebCite
  3. bio at; WebCite 25 May 2014.
  4. Lost time? He's five years younger than his 2008 Fanfiction.Net profile, also on his Fanlore page.
  5. thanart - Profile, Archived version, accessed October 14, 2015
  6. Strwriter's posts at alt.startrek.creative
  7. Voyagerbabe's posts at alt.startrek.creative
  8. Strwriter's posts at
  9. due South fanart referenced in a post is here
  10. Voyagerbabe's posts at
  11. The tale of Amy's first online scam: Ciyarra the Child Prostitute
  12. Figureheads is one, also see his fiction at; WebCite
  13. amy_player on LiveJournal. To Whom It May Concern. Posted 04 March 2007. (Archived 21 January 2013 by the Wayback Machine.) Link is now dead, but it's likely the content of this post is what is being sporked at Spork Commentary on (Thanfiction) Amy Player’s “Apology Letter”; Archive
  14. amy_player on LiveJournal. Untitled post. Posted 07 March 2007. (Archived 21 November 2011 by the Wayback Machine.)
  15. Fandom Wank Wiki. Return of the Con: Thanfiction in the Potterverse (accessed 13 Dec 2009)
  16. Andythanfiction, - SUPERNATURAL SEASON NINE FINALE APOCALARP, posted 1 Jan 2014, accessed 7 Jan 2014
  17. Fail-Fandomanon, Everyone's least favorite hobbit-channeling cult leader is LARPing again, 31 Dec 2013, accessed 7 Jan 2014
  18. Aja Romano, SPN fandom, DO NOT, I repeat, DO NOT pay andythanfiction money to do anything, and ESPECIALLY DO NOT GO WITH HIM TO A FUCKING LARP RETREAT (accessed 7 Jan 2014)
  19. through Twitter according to the Fandom Wank Wiki; Return of the Con: Thanfiction in the Potterverse (accessed 13 Dec 2009)
  20. When A Fan Hits The Shit: The Rise And Fall Of A Phony Charity; WebCite
  21. Category:Victoria Bitter images - Fan History Wiki: The Fandom History Resource, Archived version
Personal tools

Browse Categories
Shortcuts for Editors