The new adventures of Old Skywalker - As fan fiction gains respect, opportunities expand for the genre's writers

News Media Commentary
Title:	The new adventures of Old Skywalker - As fan fiction gains respect, opportunities expand for the genre's writers
Commentator:	Vanessa E. Jones
Date(s):	October 16, 2007
Venue:	online
Fandom:
External Links:	link to article; archive link
Click here for related articles on Fanlore.

The new adventures of Old Skywalker - As fan fiction gains respect, opportunities expand for the genre's writers is a 2007 article in the "Boston Globe."

Topics Discussed

• James Bow, Debra Doyle, Naomi Novik, Meg Cabot
• pseudonyms
• copyright
• fanfic
• going pro
• LiveJournal, fanfiction.net, FictionAlley, The Sugar Quill

Excerpts

Fan fiction has long been a part of Debra Doyle's life.

In high school, she concocted imaginary stories spun off of the original "Star Trek" series and handed the printed pages to her friends. Then after spending several years writing for academic purposes while getting her doctorate in Old English from the University of Pennsylvania, Doyle re-engaged her creative writing muscles by returning to fan fiction. Later, when she lived in Panama with her husband, James Macdonald, while he served in the Navy, they wrote fan fiction together inspired by "Star Wars."

"I always wanted to be a writer," says Doyle, 54, who lives in Colebrook, N.H. "Really there wasn't that much of a distinction when I got started with fan stuff and other stuff. It was pretty much things that I wrote."

Although not every fan fiction writer dreams of embarking on a career in writing, an increasing number of them are taking that path. James Bow dabbled in the fan fiction genre for about a decade before getting his first novel, "The Unwritten Girl," published last year. Isamu Fukui, a 17-year-old fan fiction writer and senior at Stuyvesant High School in New York, will have his first science fiction book, "Truancy," released in March. Naomi Novik, who wrote fan fiction as a teen before having the first book in her "Temeraire" series published last year, recently had the film rights of the first three books in the series bought by "Lord of the Rings" director Peter Jackson.

Doyle and other fan fiction writers liken their act of spinning off stories from beloved television series, film, books, or cartoons to the training done by fine artists. Painters often copy the work of artistic masters such as Degas or Renoir in an effort to learn their craft. Even Shakespeare culled stories from history and mythology to create his influential work. But modern-day issues of copyright infringement and intellectual property have made the reception of fan fiction more complicated. Add to that the discomfort created by fan fiction subgenres such as slash, which focuses on the homoerotic pairing of male characters such as Captain Kirk and Mr. Spock of "Star Trek."

As a result, a stigma clings to fan fiction that is similar to the one that taints the science fiction/fantasy genre. Some people don't want to admit that they write fan fiction. Meg Cabot, author of "The Princess Diaries," has said she only recently started acknowledging her fan fiction writing past.

Even as the publishing world addresses the genre's legal issues, some of its executives say they are open-minded about discovering talent on popular fan fiction websites such as livejournal.com, fanfiction.net, or fictionalley.org.

"I do think that the idea that publishers `troll' fanfic sites is more myth than not," Patrick Nielsen Hayden, a senior editor at Tor Books in New York, wrote in an e-mail, "but I will say this: If I had lots more spare time, I would."

Bow started writing fan fiction at the age of 14. He was a big fan of "Dr. Who," a long-running British television series about a man from another planet who can travel through time and space, and had joined a fan group called the Dr. Who Information Network, now online at dwin.org. The group's fanzine, Myth Makers, published Bow's first fan fiction contribution in 1991. Bow soon became an editor and regular contributor to the 'zine.

"The big help was from my mother," says Bow, 35, "who was herself a writer and gave me every encouragement to continue to write in fan fiction."

Bow says he spun off stories about "Dr. Who" because "the possibility of creating my own piece of the show was quite alluring." Doyle more deeply explains the allure of fan fiction writing when she says she was drawn to the fan fiction genre by "the impulse to tell more of the story or another story in the same universe or more stories about other people in the story."

The "Dr. Who" character can travel to the Napoleonic era or battle werewolves, which gives fans such as Bow plenty of creative ammunition - so much so that Bow created his own 'zine when he discovered he couldn't publish all of his work in Myth Makers. It was that secondary 'zine that helped Bow take the first step toward writing original fiction. Instead of relying on the characterization of the various actors who had played "Dr. Who," Bow decided to create his own unique "Dr. Who" character for his 'zine. He published five issues of the 'zine in the early to mid-1990s.

"Working with the character you've already played with," says Bow, "getting to show how they work, allowed me to better understand how to create characters themselves."

Although Doyle had long interspersed her fan fiction writing with original fiction writing, Bow had doubts as to whether he could make the transition to creating characters in a unique universe. He decided to make the leap after dabbling in Harry Potter fan fiction.

"What it told me was I wasn't tied to the `Dr. Who' universe," says Bow. "I could create my own characters and my own universe." In 2001 he challenged himself to write an original novel, which turned out to be "The Unwritten Girl," and see if he could get it published. Jowett says when he read Bow's "The Unwritten Girl" manuscript, he was impressed by Bow's strong characters, settings, and style.

How does writing fan fiction compare to creating original work? Bow says, "It's basically the same, other than I have to spend more time creating the hero characters, remember where they come from, what they've experienced ... how that informs their reactions. I didn't have to do that in fan fiction because it was all there. The character has been previously explored."

Doyle still occasionally returns to the fan fiction fold, most recently a year ago when she wrote some "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" fan fiction. "Every so often the urge bites," says Doyle, "because it's something I want to say about a particular story. It's a particular fun that I want to have." But she's careful to keep her two writing identities separate.

Bow, however, never wrote fan fiction under a pseudonym. In fact, he has uploaded his early work onto such sites as fictionalley.org, sugarquill.net, and fanfiction.net. With two novels published and two more in the works, he doesn't feel a need to hide that aspect of his past and wonders why anyone would.

"I think personally - and I don't mean to denigrate anyone who's written under a pseudonym - it's an insecurity," says Bow. "This is what I did; I was writing fan fiction. I did this because I enjoy it. What I've done is used something I've enjoyed doing and made a career out of it."

Fan Reaction

...it was one of those rare positive and balanced articles about fanfic, and shows off her and the other writer featured in a very good way. Also the picture of Doyle (how surprised was I to see her beaming from above the fold of the Living section?) was one of the nicest I've seen yet!

Reading the headline in Google Reader, I immediately assumed this would relate to the discovery of a cache of Elizabethan slash fanfic featuring the Capulets and Montagues. Although I am pleased that a decent fanfic piece appeared in a newspaper, I am still bitterly disappointed.

Well, cool!

That's an amazingly respectful piece, considering the current state of low-level warfare between the literature establishment and genre fiction. I'm sure a lot of that is down to Doyle and Patrick carefully explaining the background to the reporter; gratitude is in order from all of us. But even so, the reporter who wrote the article, Vanessa Jones, deserves a lot of credit for good journalism, something that's not in great supply these days. Well met and done, all of you.

Naomi Novik, who wrote fan fiction as a teen before having the first book in her "Temeraire" series published last year

I'm very amused by the past tense in this.

Also, nice article.

Hooray! How warm and fuzzy.

How refreshing and pleasant! I've always liked best the notion that writers are writers, and 'fanfic' or 'genre' or 'Biography of Ferdinand de Saussure' is just what the writer is doing, not what the writer is. Good writing is good writing, regardless. So good to see such a balanced article. Congrats!

I'll add my voice to the chorus of congratulations. It's nice to see a newspaper article about something I have at least passing knowledge about that does the topic proud.

The thing that amused me most about that article was Livejournal making it onto the list of "fan fiction websites." True, that's where most of fandom lives these days, but that's hardly the site's primary purpose, obviously. It has a sort of bitter irony to me, considering that a lot of fan writers/artists (including all of my immediate circle) moved away from Livejournal a few months ago in disgust at the administration's unfriendliness toward fandom.